Updated Nov 5, 2026· 8 min read

Key takeaways

  • Pro: Mario titles are known for approachable controls, so players of different ages can enjoy them.
  • Pro: a solo adventure with distinct worlds suits long evenings or handheld play on trips.
  • Con: it is primarily a single-player experience, so it is less suited to a group on the couch.

Unwrapping a new Switch on a holiday morning raises an immediate question: which game goes in the slot first? The answer depends less on hype and more on who will be holding the controller. A solo adventurer wants a world to wander, a family wants something that works with two controllers on a couch, and a party host needs a game that welcomes guests who have never touched the system.

The seven Nintendo titles below cover those situations, and the guide explains how to choose between them. As of 2026, first-party Switch games are still the safest starting point for most owners, because they are built for the console’s handheld and docked modes. Browse the quick table, read the short buying guide, then jump to the pick that matches your household.

Quick Picks

Product Best for Worth knowing
Super Mario Odyssey Solo platforming adventures Mario-series title with “Odyssey” suggesting a journey
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Exploration fans Zelda-series entry with “Wild” pointing to an open setting
Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Couch racing with friends “Deluxe” marks an enhanced version of the eighth Mario Kart
Animal Crossing: New Horizons Relaxed, long-term play Part of the Animal Crossing series, with a “New Horizons” subtitle
Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Party fighting games Crossover brawler with “Ultimate” in the name
Splatoon 3 Colorful team-based shooting Third main entry in the Splatoon series
Pokemon Legends: Arceus Pokemon fans who want something new Part of the Pokemon series with a “Legends” subtitle

How to Choose

Think about who plays and where

Count the people who will play at the same time. If two or more will play on one console, look for titles that mention multiplayer on the box, because many single-player adventures cannot be shared. Also consider whether the console will be docked on a television or used as a handheld; games with long text or small icons work better on a big screen, while short-session titles suit handheld play.

Check the physical versus digital trade-off

A physical cartridge can be lent, resold, and carried without using storage, while a digital copy lives on the console and needs memory card space. A good rule of thumb is that if you buy more than four or five games, a microSD card of at least 128 GB is worth adding. Cartridges also keep working after a download library fills up.

Match game length to your time

Large adventure games can run a hundred hours or more, while party games are played in short bursts. If you only have thirty minutes an evening, choose titles with short rounds or easily saved progress. If you want a game to last for months, pick an open-ended adventure or a long-running life simulation, which rewards small daily sessions.

Review the age and content rating

Every game carries an ESRB rating on the box, usually E for Everyone, E10+ for ages ten and up, or T for Teen. Parents should check the rating and read the content descriptors, which spell out violence, language, or online interaction. Games with online modes may allow chat or friend features, which can be limited through the console’s parental controls.

A smart shopping habit is to build a small library with variety instead of buying three games in the same style. One shared multiplayer title, one long solo adventure, and one relaxed daily game cover most moods. That balance means the console gets used by different people at different times, which is the best measure of value for any household.

Our Picks Reviewed

Super Mario Odyssey

Super Mario Odyssey is a Mario-series platformer, and “Odyssey” in the name hints at a journey across different worlds.

  • Pro: Mario titles are known for approachable controls, so players of different ages can enjoy them.
  • Pro: a solo adventure with distinct worlds suits long evenings or handheld play on trips.
  • Con: it is primarily a single-player experience, so it is less suited to a group on the couch.

Skip it if your household wants a game for several players at the same time.

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild carries the long-running Zelda name, and “Wild” in the title points toward a large, open outdoor setting.

  • Pro: an open-world design rewards curiosity, so players can set their own pace and goals.
  • Pro: a deep adventure gives a lot of playtime from a single purchase.
  • Con: a large, open game can feel overwhelming for people who prefer clear, linear objectives.

Skip it if you want quick, pick-up-and-play sessions or a game for several players at once.

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is the enhanced edition of the eighth Mario Kart, a series known for racing with friends.

  • Pro: racing games with multiplayer modes are ideal for a living room with several controllers.
  • Pro: short races make it easy to play a couple of rounds before dinner or a longer session at a party.
  • Con: skill gaps between players can leave newer players frustrated if rivals are far more experienced.

Skip it if you only play alone and prefer story-driven games.

Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Animal Crossing: New Horizons is part of the Animal Crossing series, a line known for slow, relaxed life-simulation play, and the subtitle points to a fresh start.

  • Pro: a relaxed, low-pressure pace suits players who want a break from competitive games.
  • Pro: it is a long-term game that fits small daily play sessions, ideal for a handheld habit.
  • Con: its slow rhythm will not appeal to those who want fast action or clear challenges.

Skip it if you want intense action or a game that can be finished in a weekend.

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is a crossover fighting game, and “Ultimate” signals a big roster pulled from many franchises.

  • Pro: a large cast of characters gives every guest a favorite, which makes it a strong party pick.
  • Pro: multiple players can join in locally, so a group can play with only the console and controllers.
  • Con: the number of characters and mechanics can overwhelm a total newcomer in competitive matches.

Skip it if your household dislikes fighting games or if you only have one controller.

Splatoon 3

Splatoon 3 is the third main game in the Splatoon series, a colorful team-based shooter.

  • Pro: a playful visual style makes a shooter feel approachable to those who normally avoid the genre.
  • Pro: team-based play means you can contribute to a win even if your aim is not perfect.
  • Con: much of the fun is in online play, which means an internet connection is likely needed.

Skip it if you do not have reliable online access or want a purely single-player experience.

Pokemon Legends: Arceus

Pokemon Legends: Arceus belongs to the Pokemon series, and the “Legends” subtitle suggests a different take on the formula.

  • Pro: fans of the series get a fresh approach to a familiar concept.
  • Pro: a single-player focus gives it a clear structure for those who enjoy collecting and exploring.
  • Con: players looking for traditional multiplayer battles may find the focus differs from earlier entries.

Skip it if you dislike collecting games or want lots of local multiplayer.

The reviews here describe each game from its title and series, not from play statistics, so the trade-offs are about genre. Racing and fighting games suit groups, platformers and open-world adventures suit solo players, and life simulations suit slow, daily play. Matching the genre to your household matters more than any single title.

Which One Fits

Start from your household rather than from a favorite franchise. Count controllers, check how much time each person has in a typical week, and note who prefers cooperation over competition. Those three facts usually point to one multiplayer game and one solo game, and the rest of the library can grow gradually from there.

  • Family movie-night energy: Mario Kart 8 Deluxe or Super Smash Bros. Ultimate.
  • Solo adventurer: Super Mario Odyssey or The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild.
  • Relaxed daily play: Animal Crossing: New Horizons.
  • Online team fans: Splatoon 3.
  • Series collectors: Pokemon Legends: Arceus.

For a night away from the screen, take a look at our guide to card games for groups, or add sound for your docked setup with a Braven speaker.

For gifts, a game is a safe present when you know the recipient’s existing library and whether they play alone or with others. A gift receipt, or a digital code that can be redeemed later, avoids the awkward duplicate. If you are unsure, a series the recipient already enjoys is almost always a better bet than a genre they have never tried.

Common Mistakes

  1. Buying a single-player game when several people want to play together.
  2. Forgetting a memory card and then running out of space for digital downloads.
  3. Skipping the age rating, especially for games with online features.
  4. Picking a huge adventure when you only have short sessions to give.
  5. Ignoring the extra controllers needed for local multiplayer.

Taking care of cartridges and the console itself prolongs enjoyment. Store cartridges in their cases, keep the dock ventilated, and charge handheld batteries before long trips. Small routines like these prevent most avoidable problems and make it easier to hand the console to a friend or relative without worry.

FAQ

Should I buy physical or digital?

Physical lets you lend and resell, while digital is convenient and takes storage. Choose based on how many games you plan to own.

Can I play these in handheld mode?

Switch games are designed to work in both handheld and docked modes, though the experience differs on a smaller screen.

Which game is best for young children?

Racing and platforming games with simple controls are usually the easiest, but always check the rating on the box.

Do I need an online subscription?

Only for some online features. Many games can be played offline, though online modes require a subscription.

What should I get for a second player?

An extra controller is the key accessory, and a headset can help with online chat; read our budget gaming headset guide for options.

B
Bass Feeds the Soul Reviews
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.